Monday, April 23, 2018

Countdown to Infinity: Ranking the Best and Worst of the MCU Films (Part 1)



The nearly insurmountable success of the Marvel Cinematic Universe at this point is a bit difficult to understate.
After a decade of operation, its grown to comprise of 10 superhero franchises, including popular iterations of previously failed franchises, before you begin to even count the successful television projects sharing the setting and continuity and the numerous projects across both film and television over the horizon.

An 18 film hot streak doesn’t exactly mean quality lacks variance however, so before watching the Avengers metanarrative come to a head, let’s look back on the best and slightly less than best of the MCU up to this point, starting with…

Thor: The Dark World


Blandness incarnate. A film so thoroughly unremarkable and forgettable that the mere act of watching it would be excruciating were it not so competently crafted and executed so as to ultimately be so average.

The film suits the purpose of putting Thor in an obstacle for 2 hours, with very little else of worth accomplished, falling back on the weaker elements of the first movie rather than truly progress the character forward, yet still contains just enough spectacle and worthwhile performances from its likable leads to be passable.

On its own, that might be enough but from the pedigree that it was coming from, “Thor: The Dark World” is easily the most disappointing entry of its entire mega franchise.


Iron Man 2

 

If “Thor’s” first sequel was the creative incarnation of lacking ambition culminating in a harmless yet disappointing experience, “Iron Man 2” is the other side of the coin.

The great elements are spectacular yet are juxtaposed by baffling plot decisions that spiral the whole thing into a giant anticlimax that makes the entire movie feel like a meandering waste of time in hindsight.

The only reason it doesn’t land below the substantially better rounded “Thor: The Dark World” is because on top of its more ambitious elements being more memorable than the entirety of that film, this one also has an excuse for its disappointment, being an infamous example of executive meddling from Marvel executives outside of the film division more concerned with shoring up their upcoming ambitious and eventually groundbreaking crossover, for which there was no prior playbook written for.

At the very least, the gamble proved to be a success, given the success of the MCU and the experience fueling Favreau to later make the stupendous 2014 indie feature “Chef.”


Spider-Man: Homecoming

 

Unpopular opinion time.

“Spider-Man: Homecoming” is a fun and mildly diverting film featuring a solid lead and one of the best villains of the MCU in the form of Michael Keaton’s The Vulture but is ultimately disposable and paling in comparison to other film’s of the setting as well as other films featuring its titular character.

While the high school themes work for a unique experience in the moment, it does little to engender confidence in the future of the brand considering where its corporate overlords want to take it in relation to how it should be naturally evolving.

Despite not being the deepest or complex “Spider-Man” or MCU film however, it ultimately gets the job done better than its messier and less ambitious contemporaries in the MCU.


Thor

 

While the “Thor” franchise has always struggled the most out of the core Avengers titles, its debut still put forth a lot of potential that it has only barely scratched the surface of.

Kenneth Branagh’s Shakespearean sensibilities assemble a family drama with genre flair that may have set a precedent for the franchise that had to be abandoned but nevertheless served as an excellent character arc designed to humanize the godliest hero of the universe by bringing out his humanity and producing a villain that has only recently been surpassed in terms of memorability for the series.



The Incredible Hulk

 

Playing into the psychological torture of a man not in control of his own body and stripped of everything that he holds dear regardless of whether he can resolve the issues that have destroyed his life, “The Incredible Hulk” is rather quaint compared to what the franchise has gone on to achieve but is easily one of the most underrated.

The chase is thrilling and the animalistic characterization of the Hulk remains one of my favorite interpretations of the character on top of Ed Norton’s self loathing laden interpretation of Bruce Banner still being my favorite take on the scientist that has made accepting Mark Ruffalo hard up until the last few years.


Guardians of the Galaxy


A solid pulp science fantasy romp that probably gets a tad too much praise for breaking the strictest of genre conventions to a genre it doesn’t particularly conform to.

Nevertheless, while the irritation of hearing people proclaim an okay space opera is the “best superhero movie ever made” despite lacking many identifiers with the genre can wear, “Guardians of the Galaxy” is an undeniably infectious good time that at least easily trumps 2 of the 3 previous “Star Wars” movies of the last 3 years.


Avengers: Age of Ultron



While the sophomore outing of Earth’s Mightiest Heroes may have a fair bit of clunkiness attached to it, it nevertheless epitomizes the raised bar of quality provided by Kevin Feige’s enterprise. Great characters, exciting set pieces, and a unique performance by James Spader as an underrated villain.

The movie may be a bit more bloated that it intended to be but still manages to mildly satisfy while tantalizing with what was to come in the future as the best phase of the MCU to date.


Iron Man


Similar to “The Incredible Hulk,” it’s hard to believe how quaint a movie that upended the entire genre feels in hindsight but “Iron Man’s” foundation of a strong well cast lead undergoing a powerful thematic arc continues to prove why it was a powerful ground on which to lay the sprawling epic of a Cinematic Universe ahead of it.

Despite an awkward climax, its lean, to the point, and earned its legacy for a reason.

No comments:

Post a Comment